Baseball Toaster: The Griddle : Ranking the GMs

Rank	Team	W	L	PCT	Division
1	Chicago Cubs	69	46	.6	C1
2	Philadelphia	62	51	.549	E1
3	Arizona	59	55	.518	W1
4	Milwaukee	64	51	.557	C2
5	St. Louis	64	52	.552	C3
6	Florida	60	54	.526	E2
7	New York Mets	59	54	.522	E3
8	Los Angeles Dodgers	56	57	.496	W2
9	Houston	54	59	.478	C4
10T	Pittsburgh	52	62	.456	C5
10T	Atlanta	52	62	.456	E4
12T	Colorado	52	63	.452	W3
12T	Cincinnati	52	63	.452	C6
14	San Francisco	48	65	.425	W4
15	San Diego	44	70	.386	W5
16	Washington	42	71	.372	E5

American League

Rank	Team	W	L	PCT	Division
1	Los Angeles Angels	71	43	.623	W1
2	Tampa Bay	68	45	.602	E1
3	Chicago White Sox	63	49	.563	C1
4	Boston	66	49	.574	E2
5	Minnesota	63	51	.553	C2
6	New York Yankees	62	52	.544	E3
7	Texas	60	55	.522	W2
8	Toronto	58	56	.509	E4
9	Detroit	55	58	.487	C3
10	Baltimore	54	59	.478	E5
11	Oakland	53	60	.469	W3
12	Kansas City	53	62	.461	C4
13	Cleveland	49	64	.434	C5
14	Seattle	44	70	.386	W4

Random Game Callbacks

Select a date:

So where is that book?

Personal favorites that I wrote

The last batter to reach on catcher's interference was ...

Lyle Overbay of Toronto by Gerald Laird of Texas on August 1, 2008

FAQs

At least I think they should be.

Cycle alerts

Yellow alert - Player needs triple for cycle
Orange alert - Player needs double for cycle
Red alert - Player need single for cycle

If a player needs a home run for the cycle, the level of the alert varies depending upon the determination of the Cycle Detection Warning System, which is headquartered in Thief River Falls, Minnesota.

Syndication

About the Toaster

Baseball Toaster runs on some experimental software called Fairpole. It's still under development.

For more information, please visit the Fairpole blog, or read the FAQ.

Ranking the GMs

2007-01-22 06:55

by Bob Timmermann

Dayn Perry of Foxsports.com ranks the 30 baseball GMs in terms of quality from John Schuerholz at the top all the way down to Bill Bavasi pulling up the rear.

The lowest ranked GM who has had a team make the postseason is Jim Hendry, who clocks in at #25. For pennant winners, it's Tim Purpura of Houston at #18. Bill Stoneman is the lowest of any current GM who has had a team win the World Series, and Perry puts him at #12.

Link via BTF.

Advertisement

Comments

2007-01-22 07:51:14

1. D4P

"We're number 21! We're number 21!"

2007-01-22 09:04:40

2. Jim Dean

Those familiar with my ranting at the Bronx Banter will be surprised that I think Cashman is actually too low. And Epstein seems way too high after the last year.

But overall I'd think most of us would agree with the generalities of the list.

Isn't there a better way though? Maybe Winshares gained versus lost over the years then take some yearly average? Has someone done this work that I've missed?

2007-01-22 09:42:07

3. Rich Mahogany

Except for some no-brainer high- and low-end choices, this list is a crapshoot.

Dayton Moore at 19, J.P. Ricciardi at 20 kills the whole list for me. As does Bill Stoneman at 12 - if a GM on a small-market team made the same "questionable moves" that Stoneman did, the team would blow its shot at contention.

2007-01-22 13:10:17

4. Voxter

It's a nitpick, but how does Terry Ryan get ranked ahead of Billy Beane despite fewer playoff appearances in more seasons -- and the fact that the AL Central was easily the weak sister of AL until fairly recently?

Anyway, it's good to see that it's not just Mariners fans who think that Bavasi is the worst. In fact, I've been known to say, "Bill Bavasi is the worst." To which people often reply, "The worst? Really? Surely not worse than dysentery." And I say, "Yes, Bill Bavasi is worse than dysentery."

I also remember thinking what a great thing it would be for the Pirates finally to be out from under the suffocating stewardship of Cam Bonifay. I mean, seriously, how do you fire Cam Bonifay and not find someone who is an improvement on him? I wouldn't have believed it possible until it happened.

2007-01-22 13:56:22

5. dzzrtRatt

Bob, this sentence was a bit puzzling...

The lowest ranked GM who has a had team make the postseason is...

What is a "had team?" Is it like being "had" by a practical joker? Are you saying that some GM's have the ability to trick their team into thinking they're good? If so, I would think that kind of GM should be rated higher.

Or do you mean "had" in the sense of "You had me at 'Hello'?" A team so in thrall to their GM that they perform above their talent level, just to prove their undying love? Again, that's the kind of GM I want on the Dodgers.

2007-01-22 14:05:58

6. dzzrtRatt

Okay, now to be serious: Perry's list seems like a fool's errand, because it compares GMs who've been on the job for a long time, and have presumably developed their skills with GMs (including Colletti) who are still finding their way.

This comment about Colletti made me wonder if Steve had taken over Perry's column:

The Dodgers netted a playoff appearance in Colletti's first season, but in the process he traded away a number of high-ceiling prospects.

Like who, exactly? Guzman and Jackson were at one time high-ceiling prospects, but the roof caved in, and that's why they were traded for so little return. Aybar and Navarro were medium-ceiling prospects. The top prospects are still with the team, so far.

The minute Colletti trades LA's equivalents of Nathan, Liriano and Bonser for the equivalent of A.J. Pierzynski, I'll jump on the "he's just like Sabean" bandwagon. But that hasn't nearly happened yet. Sabean is the kind of GM who would trade prospects to get Luis Gonzalez or Juan Pierre. Colletti just signs them as free agents. Problematic, but nowhere near as bad.

2007-01-22 15:29:19

7. trainwreck

I am not the biggest Ned fan, but how is Dayton Moore higher rated. He just gave Gil Meche 55 million dollars. At least, Ned's team can absorb bad contracts easier and he has actually had a winning team.

Advertisement