The situation: the Detroit Tigers have Omar Infante on third and Brandon Inge on first with none out and Curtis Granderson at the plate. It's a 1-1 game in the seventh in Detroit with the Yankees visiting. Andy Pettitte is on the mound.
Tigers manager Jim Leyland gives Granderson the squeeze sign. Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez was already playing in and is charging on the play. Infante breaks for home, but Rodriguez is breaking with him. Pettitte is a bit confused and throws home after a hesitation, but Rodriguez is already in front of home plate. The pitch is caught by Rodriguez in front of the plate.
So, what do you do now if you're the home plate umpire?
Again this play is adapted from a situation in this book.