Baseball Toaster: The Griddle : Toaster Draft Chat

Toaster Draft Chat

2005-06-06 22:22

by Ken Arneson

I thought I'd put up a blog entry to discuss the draft as it happens. I'll be following it all day long, so I'll try to fill in the first 200 picks as they are made below, as quickly as I can.

I made a prospect list cobbled together from a mixture of various sources. The rankings in parentheses are mine, and are intended just as a guide to help follow the draft as it goes along, not as a judgment.

Show/Hide Round 1

1. Diamondbacks  Justin Upton, SS, HS, VA (1)
2. Royals        Alex Gordon, 3B, Nebraska (2)
3. Mariners      Jeff Clement, C, USC (9)
4. Nationals     Ryan Zimmerman, 3B, Virginia (4)
5. Brewers       Ryan Braun, 3B, Miami (12)
6. Blue Jays     Ricky Romero, LHP, Cal St-Fullerton (7)
7. Rockies       Troy Tulowitzki, SS, Long Beach St (3)
8. Devil Rays    Wade Townsend, RHP, no school (13)
9. Mets          Mike Pelfrey, RHP, Wichita St (8)
10. Tigers       Cameron Maybin, OF, HS, NC (5)
11. Pirates      Andrew McCutchen, OF, HS, FL (11)
12. Reds         Jay Bruce, OF, HS, TX (16)
13. Orioles      Brandon Snyder, C, HS, VA (32)
14. Indians      Trevor Crowe, OF, Arizona (23)
15. White Sox    Lance Broadway, RHP, TCU (38)
16. Marlins      Chris Volstad, RHP, HS, FL (17)
17. Yankees      C.J. Henry, SS, HS, OK (18)
18. Padres       Cesar Carrillo, RHP, Miami (15)
19. Rangers      John Mayberry, RF, Stanford (36)
20. Cubs         Mark Pawalek, LHP, HS, UT (14)
21. Athletics    Cliff Pennington, SS, Texas A&M (24)
22. Marlins      Aaron Thompson, LHP, HS, TX (51)
23. Red Sox      Jacoby Ellsbury, OF, Oregon St (20)
24. Astros       Brian Bogusevic, LHP, Tulane (19)
25. Twins        Matt Garza, RHP, Fresno St (52)
26. Red Sox      Craig Hansen, RHP, St. John's (10)
27. Braves       Joey Devine, RHP, NC St (31)
28. Cardinals    Colby Rasmus, OF, HS, AL (27)
29. Marlins      Jacob Marceaux, RHP, McNeese St. (39)
30. Cardinals    Tyler Greene, SS, Georgia Tech (35)

Show/Hide Round 1 Supplemental

31. Diamondbacks  Matt Torra, RHP, Massachusetts (22)
32. Rockies       Chaz Roe, RHP, HS, KY (33)
33. Indians       John Drennen, OF, HS, CA (25)
34. Marlins       Ryan Tucker, RHP, HS, CA (83)
35. Padres        Cesar Ramos, LHP, Long Beach St (21)
36. Athletics     Travis Buck, OF/3B, Arizona St (45)
37. Angels        Trevor Bell, RHP, HS, CA (58)
38. Astros        Eli Iorg, OF, Tennessee (61)
39. Twins         Henry Sanchez, 1B, HS, CA (40)
40. Dodgers       Luke Hochevar, RHP, Tennessee (6)
41. Braves        Beau Jones, LHP, HS, LA (169)
42. Red Sox       Clay Buchholz, RHP, JC, TX (43)
43. Cardinals     Mark McCormick, RHP, Baylor (26)
44. Marlins       Sean West, LHP, HS, LA (50)
45. Red Sox       Jed Lowrie, 2B, Stanford (30)
46. Cardinals     Tyler Herron, RHP, HS, FL (47)
47. Red Sox       Michael Bowden, RHP, HS, IL (29)
48. Orioles       Garrett Olson, LHP, Cal Poly (70)

Show/Hide Round 2

49. Diamondbacks  Matt Green, RHP, Louisiana-Monroe (77)
50. Royals        Jeff Bianchi, SS, HS, PA (130)
51. Dodgers       Ivan DeJesus, SS, Puerto Rico (107)
52. Rockies       Daniel Carte, OF, Winthrop (42)
53. Athletics     Craig Italiano, RHP, HS, TX (48)
54. Twins         Paul Kelly, SS, HS, TX (69)
55. Rockies       Zach Simons, RHP, JC, ID (116)
56. Devil Rays    Chris Mason, RHP, UNC Greensboro (71)
57. Red Sox       Jonathan Egan, C, HS, GA (102)
58. Angels        Ryan Mount, SS, HS, CA (62)
59. Pirates       William Corley, OF, Mississippi St (201)
60. Reds          Travis Wood, LHP, HS, AR (120)
61. Orioles       Nolan Reimold, OF, Bowling Green (167)
62. Indians       Stephen Head, 1B, Mississippi (44)
63. Yankees       J. Brent Cox, RHP, Texas (46)
64. Marlins       Kris Harvey, OF/RHP, Clemson (76)
65. Phillies      Mike Costanzo, 3B, Coastal Carolina (88)
66. Padres        Chase Headley, 3B, Tennessee (89)
67. Rangers       John Whittleman, 3B, HS, TX (190)
68. Cubs          Donald Veal, LHP, JC, AZ (74)
69. Athletics     Jared Lansford, RHP, HS, CA (165)
70. Cardinals     Josh Wilson, RHP, HS, TX (125)
71. Angels        P.J. Phillips, SS, HS, GA (49)
72. Astros        Ralph Henriquez, C, HS, FL (--)
73. Twins         Kevin Slowey, RHP, Winthrop (79)
74. Dodgers       Josh Wall, RHP, HS, LA (55)
75. Braves        Yuneil Escobar, SS, Cuba (96)
76. Padres        Nick Hundley, C, Arizona (66)
77. Braves        Jeff Lyman, RHP, HS, CA (73)
78. Cardinals     Nick Webber, RHP, Central Missouri St. (81)

Show/Hide Round 2 Supplemental

79. Marlins       Brett Hayes, C/OF, Nevada (57)
80. Twins         Drew Thompson, SS, HS, FL (60)

Show/Hide Round 3

81. Diamondbacks  Jason Neighborgall, RHP, Georgia Tech (98)
82. Royals        Chris Nicoll, RHP, UC Irvine (111)
83. Diamondbacks  Micah Owings, RHP, Tulane (95)
84. Twins         Brian Duensing, LHP, Nebraska-Lincoln (--)
85. Brewers       William Inman, RHP, HS, VA
86. Blue Jays     Brian Pettway, 1B, Mississippi (90)
87. Rockies       Kyle Hancock, RHP, HS, TX (160)
88. Devil Rays    Bryan Morris, RHP, HS, TN (41)
89. Astros        Tommy Manzella, SS, Tulane (119)
90. Tigers        Chris Robinson, C, Illinois (140)
91. Pirates       James Boone, CF, Missouri-Columbia (--)
92. Reds          Zach Ward, RHP, Gardner-Webb (94)
93. Orioles       Brandon Erbe, RHP, HS, MD (175)
94. Indians       Nick Weglarz, 1B, HS, ON (91)
95. White Sox     Richard Brooks, RHP, East Carolina (--)
96. Marlins       Matt Goyen, LHP, Georgia College (108)
97. Phillies      Matt Maloney, LHP, Mississippi (109)
98. Padres        Josh Geer, RHP, Rice (110)
99. Rangers       Taylor Teagarden, C, Texas (28)
100. Cubs         Mark Holliman, RHP, Mississippi (159)
101. Athletics    Vince Mazzaro, RHP, HS, NJ (155)
102. Indians      Jensen Lewis, RHP, Vanderbilt (103)
103. Angels       Sean O'Sullivan, RHP, HS, CA (53)
104. Astros       Josh Lindblom, RHP, HS, IN (68)
105. Twins        Ryan Mullins, LHP, Vanderbilt (86)
106. Dodgers      Sergio Pedroza, LF, Cal St Fullerton (--)
107. Braves       Jordan Schafer, CF, HS, FL (177)
108. Cubs         Mike Billek, RHP, Central Florida (126)
109. Yankees      Brett Gardner, OF, Charleston (197)
110. Cardinals    Daryl Jones, OF, HS, TX (161)

Show/Hide Round 4

111. Diamondbacks  Mark Romanczuk, LHP, Stanford (--)
112. Royals        Joseph Dickerson, CF, HS (--)
113. Mariners      Justin Thomas, LHP, Youngstown St
114. Nationals     Justin Maxwell, OF, Maryland (72)
115. Brewers       Matthew Gamel, 3B, JC (--)
116. Blue Jays     Ryan Patterson, OF, LSU (168)
117. Rockies       Brandon Durden, LHP, Georgia College (101)
118. Devil Rays    Jeremy Hellickson, RHP, HS, IA (65)
119. Mets          Hector Pellot, 2B, HS, PR (--)
120. Tigers        Kevin Whelan, RHP, Texas A&M (85)
121. Pirates       Brent Lillibridge, SS, Washington (84)
122. Reds          Sam Lecure, RHP, no school (--)
123. Orioles       Kieron Pope, OF, HS, GA (170)
124. Indians       Jordan Brown, 1B, Arizona (144)
125. White Sox     Chris Getz, 2B, Michigan (157)
126. Marlins       Gabriel Sanchez, C, Miami (--)
127. Phillies      Mike Durant, 3B, HS, CA (135)
128. Padres        Michael Baxter, LF, Vanderbilt (--)
129. Rangers       Shane Funk, RHP, HS, FL (--)
130. Cubs          Dylan Johnston, SS, HS, AZ (--)
131. Athletics     James Shull, RHP, Cal Poly SLO (--)
132. Giants        Ben Copeland, OF, Pittsburgh (121)
133. Angels        Brian Matusz, LHP, HS, AZ (64)
134. Astros        Josh Flores, JC, (--)
135. Twins         Michael Moore, C, East Tennessee St (--)
136. Dodgers       Josh Bell, 3B, HS, FL (97)
137. Braves        Mike Broadway, RHP, HS, IL (129)
138. Red Sox       William Blue, RHP, HS (--)
139. Yankees       Lance Pendleton, RHP/OF, Rice (142)
140. Cardinals     Brian Anderson, C, HS, CA (--)

Show/Hide Round 5

141. Diamondbacks  Christopher Rahl, RF, William & Mary (--)
142. Royals        Sean Hayes, SS, Franklin Pierce (--)
143. Mariners      Stephen Kahn, RHP, Loyola Marymount (127)
144. Nationals     Ryan DeLaughter, OF, HS, TX (193)
145. Brewers       Kevin Roberts, RHP, Houston (152)
146. Blue Jays     Jonathan Fowler, LHP, Mississippi (--)
147. Rockies       Josh Sullivan, RHP, Auburn (128)
148. Devil Rays    Michael McCormick, 3B, HS, OR (--)
149. Mets          Drew Butera, C, Central Florida (137)
150. Tigers        Jeff Larish, 1B/OF, Arizona St (114)
151. Pirates       Jeffrey Sues, RHP, Vanderbilt (--)
152. Reds          James Avery, RHP, Niagara (139)
153. Orioles       Reid Hamblet, RHP, Biola (198)
154. Indians       Kevin Dixon, RHP, Minnesota St-Mankato (--)
155. White Sox     Ryan Rote, RHP, Vanderbilt (--)
156. Marlins       Kyle Winters, RHP, HS, CO (213)
157. Phillies      Brett Harker, RHP, Charleston (--)
158. Padres        Seth Johnston, 2B/SS, Texas (63)
159. Rangers       Michael Kirkman, RHP, HS, FL (158)
160. Cubs          Scott Taylor, RHP, HS, VA (--)
161. Athletics     Scott Deal, RHP, HS, WA (--)
162. Giants        Daniel Griffin, RHP, Niagara (--)
163. Angels        Tommy Mendoza, RHP, HS, FL (172)
164. Astros        Wilson Hart, 3B, USC (--)
165. Twins         Steven Tolleson, SS, South Carolina (166)
166. Dodgers       John Meloan, RHP, Arizona (146)
167. Braves        William Startup, RHP, Georgia (--)
168. Red Sox       Reid Engel, OF, HS, CO (--)
169. Yankees       Zachary Kroenke, RHP, Nebraska-Lincoln (--)
170. Cardinals     Mitch Boggs, RHP, Georgia (138)

Show/Hide Round 6

171. Diamondbacks  Greg Smith, LHP, Louisiana St (184)
172. Royals        Ryan DiPietro, E Connecticut St (--)
173. Mariners      Michael Lynn, RHP, HS, IN (205)
174. Nationals     Marco Estrada, RHP, Long Beach St (--)
175. Brewers       Steven Hammonds, LHP, Long Beach St (--)
176. Blue Jays     Josh Bell, C, Auburn (100)
177. Rockies       Corey Wimberly, 2B, Alcorn St (--)
178. Devil Rays    Greg Reinhard, RHP, Wisconsin-Whitewater (--)
179. Mets          Greg Cain, CF, HS, CA  (--)
180. Tigers        Clete Thomas, OF, Auburn (92)
181. Pirates       Cameron Blair, 2B, Texas Tech (183)
182. Reds          Jeffrey Stevens, RHP, Loyola-Marymount (--)
183. Orioles       William Owen, RHP, Belmont  (--)
184. Indians       Joseph Ness, RHP, Ball St (--)
185. White Sox     Aaron Cunningham, LF, JC, WA  (203)
186. Marlins       James Guerrero, SS, San Diego St
187. Phillies      Justin Blaine, LHP, San Diego (178)
188. Padres        Neil Jamison, RHP, Long Beach St (211)
189. Rangers       German Duran, 2B, Weatherford (--)
190. Cubs          Kyle Reynolds, SS, Baylor (--)
191. Athletics     Justin Sellers, SS, HS, CA (200)
192. Giants        Kyle Cuthbertson, JC, CA (--)
193. Angels        Jeremy Moore, LF, HS (--)
194. Astros        Brandon Barnes, LF, JC, CA (--)
195. Twins         John Wilson, RF, HS, TX (--)
196. Dodgers       Brent Leach, LHP, Brent St (--)
197. Braves        Tyler Bullock, RHP, Baylor (--)
198. Red Sox       Jeffrey Corsaletti, CF, Florida (--)
199. Yankees       Douglas Fister, RHP, Fresno St (--)
200. Cardinals     Wilfredo Pujols, RF, HS, MO (--)

Show/Hide Still on the board after six rounds

Justin Bristow, SS, HS, VA (34)
Jordan Danks, OF, HS, TX (37)
David Adams, 3B/SS, HS, FL (54)
Vance Worley, RHP, HS, CA (56)
Cody Satterwhite, RHP, HS, MS (59)
Reese Havens, SS, HS, SC (67)
Justin Smoak, 1B, HS, SC (75)
Zach Putnam, 3B, HS, MI (78)
Tim Lincecum, RHP, Washington (80)
Robert Ray, RHP, Texas A&M (82)
Kenny Maiques, RHP, JC, CA (87)
Jeremy Bleich, LHP, HS, LA (93)
Pedro Alvarez, 3B, HS, NY (99)
Diallo Fon, OF, HS, CA (104)
David Cooper, OF, HS, CA (105)
David Duncan, LHP, HS, OH (106)
Josh Zeid, RHP, HS, CT (112)
Buster Posey, RHP, HS, GA (113)
Kyle Russell, OF, HS, TX (115)
Austin Jackson, OF, HS, TX (117)
Miers Quigley, LHP, HS, GA (118)
Alan Horne, RHP, Florida (122)
Wade Miley, LHP, HS, LA (123)
Mike Bell, 3B, CC, TX (124)
Brett Jacobson, RHP, HS, AZ (131)
DeSean Jackson, OF, HS, CA (132)
Tyson Ross, RHP, HS, CA (133)
Jarred Bogany, OF, HS, TX (134)
Jeremy Slayden, OF, Georgia Tech (136)
Brett Wallace, 3B, HS, CA (141)
Andrew Lopez, OF, HS, CA (143)
Iain Sebastian, RHP, HS, GA (145)
Anthony Varvaro, RHP, St. John's (147)
Ike Davis, 1B, HS, AZ (148)
Danny Powers, RHP, Central Missouri St. (149)
Evan Frederickson, LHP, HS, VA (150)
Bryant Beaver, RHP, JC, OK (151)
Carlos Hereaud, SS, HS, TX (153)
Chris Dominguez, 3B, HS, FL (154)
Mike Colla, RHP, HS, CA (156)
Deunte Heath, RHP, JC, GA (162)
Dexter Carter, RHP, HS, NC (163)
David Huff, LHP, JC, CA (164)
Michael Campbell, OF, South Carolina (171)
Michael Nix, RHP, Auburn (173)
Brian Needham, RHP, HS, TX (174)
Matt Nevarez, RHP, HS, CA (176)
Charlie Cutler, C, HS, CA (179)
Elliot Jones, 2B, Vanderbilt (180)
Brent Milleville, C, HS, KS (181)
Milton Loo, 3B, CC, HI (182)
Paul Phillips, RHP, Oakland (185)
Daniel McCutchen, RHP, Oklahoma (186)
Brian Hernandez, C, Vanderbilt (187)
Aaron Weatherford, RHP, HS, AL (188)
Shooter Hunt, RHP, HS, NJ (189)
Yahmed Yema, OF, Florida Int'l (191)
Mark Wagner, C, UC Irvine (192)
Brad Barragar, RHP, JC, CA (194)
Daniel Hudson, RHP, HS, VA (195)
Karl Amonite, 1B, Auburn (196)
Jake Rasner, RHP, HS, NV (199)
Jason Ogata, SS, HS, OR (202)
Allen Langdon, OF, HS, ID (203)
Trevor Holder, RHP, HS, AL (204)
Jim Brauer, RHP, Michigan (206)
Brandon James, RHP, HS, PA (208)
Francisco Figueroa, OF, Miami (209)
Jemile Weeks, SS, HS, FL (210)
David DiNatale, OF, HS, FL (212)
Tim Murphy, LHP, HS, CA (214)
Steven Pearce, 1B, South Carolina (215)

The pace picked up in the sixth round, and I can't keep up anymore. So you'll have to go to MLB.com for the rest of the picks.

Comments

2005-06-07 10:18:17

1. Ken Arneson

Dang, I was hoping Crowe would fall to the A's. Went a lot earlier than I had heard.

2005-06-07 12:00:37

2. Cliff Corcoran

Ken, you're the man. Yanks are looking good thus far getting a solid pick in the first round that has the potential to become a Jeter/Bernie type in five years when Jeter and Rodriguez are old and off the books, and a kid that could be in the mix to replace Mariano even sooner. As the body dies, the heart beats new life.

2005-06-07 12:18:41

3. Ken Arneson

The Indians were reading my mind today. I wanted Drennan in the supplemental round, too.

Yanks and Red Sox both went for relievers early.

If the Dodgers can sign Hochevar, that'll be the best pick in the draft, I think.

Three high school pitchers for the A's so far. I'm stunned.

Andrew Shimmin

Milton Bradley of Texas by Chris Coste of Philadelphia on June 28, 2008